Legal Steps After Being Hit by an Uninsured Driver
Surprising fact: in 2024 about 8% of U.S. motorists drove without insurance, a number that can turn a routine trip into a stressful accident report and claims fight.
We focus first on health and safety, then on the practical actions that protect our claim and speed review with our insurance company. Small, clear tasks—calling police, taking photos, and collecting witness information—make a big difference.
Next we explain how our coverage and auto insurance tools, such as uninsured motorist protections or personal injury protection, can help when the at-fault motorist lacks liability coverage.
Finally, we preview the options we’ll weigh: using our own policy, negotiating with the insurer, or pursuing other routes under state rules. We’ll also list the records to keep—medical notes, repair estimates, and police reports—so we know what to expect as we move from scene to settlement.
What we should do at the scene to protect our health, rights, and claim
When a collision happens, our first moves shape both our health outcomes and any later claims. We focus on getting care, preserving evidence, and recording facts that insurers and investigators will need.
Call 911, stay put, and prioritize medical care
We call 911 immediately and stay at the scene unless medical evacuation is required. Seeking prompt medical care helps treat injuries and creates a medical record that supports our case.
Report to police and document the scene
We tell the officer what happened and request the incident number and report details. Then we document with clear photos of vehicle positions, damage, skid marks, and road conditions.
Collect driver and vehicle details and look for proof of no insurance
We gather the other driver’s name, license number, contact, and car details. We ask for their insurance information and note any admission of no coverage as possible proof.
Quick checklist:
- Save witness names and brief statements.
- Note any immediate pain, dizziness, or EMS observations.
- Back up photos and information to the cloud.
Legal Steps After Being Hit by an Uninsured Driver: a practical roadmap
After the crash, quick organization of evidence and paperwork gives us the best chance to protect our health and claim.
We preserve evidence right away. Keep photos, the police report number, medical records, repair estimates, and any written proof the other driver lacked coverage.
Notify our insurer and review policy details
We notify our insurer promptly to open a claim and avoid delays. We check our auto insurance declarations page to confirm deductibles and coverage types.
When to contact an attorney
We consider contacting an attorney before long recorded statements. Early legal contact can help us choose options and manage insurer communications if the injury is serious.
"Collect the facts, save receipts, and get medical care—those items shape how a claim settles."
- Request the official police report and confirm the facts.
- Keep a symptom diary and all bills to document injury progression.
- Get at least two repair estimates and retain invoices.
| Document | Why it matters | Who needs it |
|---|---|---|
| Photos | Shows damage and scene conditions | We and our adjuster |
| Police report | Official account for the uninsured motorist claim | Insurer and attorney |
| Medical records | Proves injury and treatment | Claims examiner |
Using UM, UIM, PIP, and MedPay to cover injuries, vehicle damage, and losses
Knowing which parts of our policy apply helps us get care and fix our car while liability is sorted. We check our declarations page and notify the insurer so claims can start fast.
Uninsured motorist coverage: what it pays and how claims work
Uninsured motorist coverage pays for our injury and, where the policy allows, pain and suffering if the at-fault person lacks insurance. UM often applies to hit-and-run or phantom vehicle incidents, but many policies require a police report within 72 hours and insurer notice within 30 days.
Underinsured motorist: bridging low at-fault limits
UIM fills the gap between the at-fault liability limits and our own limits. For example, $100,000 UM minus a $25,000 liability payment leaves $75,000 available as UIM, subject to stacking rules and any consent-to-settle clauses.
Personal Injury Protection and MedPay: fast medical care and wage support
PIP and MedPay cover immediate medical bills and partial wage loss so we can treat injuries quickly. In Oregon, PIP may pay up to $15,000 for medical expenses and significant wage and essential services benefits within one year.
Collision and property damage when UM property coverage is absent
If our policy lacks UM property coverage, we use collision or comprehensive to repair the vehicle. We should ask the adjuster whether deductibles are reduced or waived in hit-and-run claims.
"Confirm limits, keep bills and repair estimates, and meet reporting deadlines to preserve all available coverage."
| Coverage | Main benefit | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| UM | Injury and pain/suffering | Police report & insurer notice deadlines |
| UIM | Gap between limits | Stacking and consent rules may apply |
| PIP / MedPay | Medical bills & wage loss | Fast payment while liability is determined |
Deadlines, state rules, and special scenarios that can make or break our claim
Some filing windows are short; acting fast preserves our rights and available insurance benefits.
Police reporting for hit-and-run and phantom vehicle claims
Many states require we report hit-and-run or phantom vehicle incidents to police within 72 hours. Getting a formal police report quickly helps establish the facts and supports any uninsured motorist claim.
Notify our insurer promptly—often within 30 days—to avoid coverage disputes and to meet strict notice rules under state law.
Typical UM claim timeframes and why filing sooner helps
UM claim deadlines vary, but many states set filing limits near one year. Filing sooner—ideally within a week—makes evidence and witness statements easier to confirm.
When the car is insured but the driver isn’t
If the vehicle has insurance, liability may still apply when the driver had permission. Named-driver exclusions, lack of permission, or theft can change coverage fast.
- Follow state-specific reporting rules and keep a copy of the police report.
- File a UM claim early and diarize key dates and deadlines.
- Confirm whether the vehicle was stolen, used without permission, or covered under an endorsement.
- Get written confirmation of coverage decisions from the insurer and escalate disputes quickly.
"Keep every report, note key dates, and get coverage decisions in writing so deadlines don't derail our cases."
When UM isn’t enough: suing an uninsured driver and how recovery actually works
Winning a judgment is one thing; collecting money from someone with no assets is another challenge.
We first assess whether the uninsured driver has wages, a bank account, or property worth pursuing. If the defendant is judgment-proof, litigation may cost more than it returns.
Assessing ability to pay
We search public records and ask our attorney to do a financial check. A quick asset review helps decide whether suing makes sense given expected costs and timelines.
Filing suit and proving losses
To sue uninsured driver we must show fault and quantify damages: medical bills for our injury, lost wages, and vehicle or property repairs. Clear invoices and expert reports strengthen our case.
Collecting on a judgment
State law often allows wage garnishment, bank levies, or property liens. In practice, many judgments are hard to collect if the driver lacks assets.
- We weigh likely recovery against upfront costs and attorney fees.
- Small claims court can be faster and cheaper for limited car or property losses.
- Keep our insurer informed if subrogation or reimbursement may affect compensation.
"A judgment is only useful if the defendant has something to pay with."
Disputes with our insurer: negotiating fair compensation and arbitration options
Negotiating with the insurer often comes down to paperwork, timing, and persistence.
We cooperate with the insurance company adjuster, but we also insist on written explanations for coverage decisions and any settlement numbers. A clear demand package—medical records, bills, wage loss, and future care estimates—gives us leverage and makes compensation requests credible.
Working with the adjuster and documenting damages
Keep every record and log each contact with the adjuster. Note dates, names, and short summaries of calls or emails.
Prepare to attend an independent medical exam or an examination under oath if the policy requires it. We consult counsel before these events when damages are significant.
Arbitration versus filing a lawsuit
Many policies let us choose arbitration instead of court. Arbitration can be faster and less costly, but it is often binding.
| Option | Speed | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Negotiate with insurer | Moderate | May need persistence |
| Arbitration | Fast | Binding decision |
| Lawsuit | Slow | Higher cost, appeals possible |
Subrogation: when our insurer pursues the other motorist
After paying our claim, the insurance company may try to recover funds from the uninsured motorist. Real-world recoveries can be rare if the at-fault party lacks assets.
"Keep a tidy claim file so any mediator, arbitrator, or judge quickly understands our damages."
We weigh options: continue negotiating, invoke arbitration, or sue the insurer for bad faith when counsel advises. Stay professional in all contact and save every piece of information that supports our case.
Costs, premiums, and practical next steps to control financial fallout
Controlling the financial fallout starts with quick, simple choices about repairs, medical care, and counsel.
Attorney fee structures and what we should expect
Most personal injury lawyers work on contingency, usually 25–40% of recovery. For small claims, counsel may use hourly fees ($150–$500), flat fees, or a smaller contingency.
We compare projected attorney costs to likely recovery so fees don't eclipse our net award.
Will a UM claim raise our insurance rates?
Filing a UM claim usually does not increase our auto insurance premium since the crash wasn't our fault.
We still confirm with our insurance company and keep records that show the other driver was at fault for renewals and any rate review.
Prioritizing repairs, medical bills, and lost wage documentation
Use PIP or MedPay first for immediate medical bills and wage loss while UM is pending.
Prioritize essential car repairs so we keep the car safe. Use approved shops and save all invoices and estimates.
- Verify coverage limits and rental help with the insurer.
- Organize medical bills, wage records, and repair receipts early.
- Create a simple budget for co-pays, deductibles, and any uncovered property damage.
Conclusion
In short, quick reporting, steady medical care, and organized records make the difference in recovering after a crash with an uninsured motorist.
Report hit-and-run or phantom vehicle incidents to police promptly and notify our insurer within required timeframes. Use personal injury protection or MedPay for immediate care and to cover initial bills.
We should use uninsured motorist and UIM coverage where available and weigh litigation only when the other party has recoverable assets. Take photos, save repair estimates, and keep all medical invoices to support compensation and property damage claims.
.
If a case is complex—catastrophic injury or death—we contact a trusted professional. Follow state rules, meet deadlines, and keep our auto insurance and coverage choices up to date so we’re ready if we’re hit uninsured again.
